Cartoon Contender breaks down all of the below-the-line categories that animated shows are eligible for at the 2025 Primetime Emmys.
A website dedicated to animation, awards, and everything in between.
Credit: Invincible (Amazon Prime Video), Devil May Cry (Netlfix), The Legend of Vox Machina (Amazon Prime Video)
There are three categories at the Primetime Emmys where we’re guaranteed to see animation represented: Outstanding Animated Program (obviously), Outstanding Individual Achievement in Animation (a non-competitive juried award), and Outstanding Character Voice-Over Performance (which could still see a few nominees from live-action productions, i.e. Ke Huy Quan for The White Lotus). Actually, make that four categories, as the Emmys have apparently introduced a new award: Outstanding Sound Editing For an Animated Program, which strangely isn’t listed in the rules of procedures guide. In any case, these are the most animation-friendly categories, although they’re not the only ones where animation has been submitted.
Various animated programs have been entered for consideration in writing, music, casting, editing, and other categories. Will any of them be nominated, though? The Music Peer Group has occasionally recognized animation, although the Writers Peer Group remains a live-action club, despite the rich storytelling that can be found in modern animation, both comedy and drama. Whether or not any nominations materialize, I’m breaking down every animated program that’s been submitted in below-the-line categories.
Outstanding Casting For a Comedy Series
Big Mouth
Krapopolis
#1 Happy Family USA
Sausage Party: Foodtopia
The Second Best Hospital in the Galaxy
Outstanding Casting For a Drama Series
Arcane
Batman: Caped Crusader
Creature Commandos
Devil May Cry
Invincible
The Legend of Vox Machina
Twilight of the Gods
What If…?
Outstanding Commercial
Krapopolis Season One Rekrap - Fox Entertainment
Patrick Starship Enterprise - Paramount +
The Sims & The Sims 2 Legacy Collections Official Reveal Trailer - Electronic Arts Inc.
The Spider Within: A Spider-Verse Story - Kevin Love Fund/EIF
Yeti - Olipop Holiday
Outstanding Emerging Media Program
Crypto: The Game – Resurrection Island
Impulse: Playing With Reality
Mobile Suit Gundam: Silver Phantom
Paramount & Gamefam: First Playable Story On Roblox
Resolution: A Cinephonic Rhapsody For The Soul
Outstanding Title Design
Arcane
Batman: Caped Crusader
Common Side Effects
Creature Commandos
Devil May Cry
Invincible
The Legend of Vox Machina
Sausage Party: Foodtopia
Secret Level
Tomb Raider: The Legend of Lara Croft
Twilight of the Gods
Outstanding Music Composition For a Series (Original Dramatic Score)
American Dad!: “What Great Advancements,” Joel McNeely
Arcane: “Heavy Is the Crown,” Alex Saver, Alexander Temple
Batman: Caped Crusader: “Kiss of the Catwoman,” Frederik Wiedmann
Big Mouth: “Why Do We Go Through Puberty?,” Mark Rivers
Castlevania: Nocturne: “A Line of Great Heroes,” Trevor Morris, Trey Toy
Common Side Effects: “Cliff’s Edge,” Nic Snyder
Creature Commandos: “Chasing Squirrels,” Clint Mansell, Kevin Kiner
Devil May Cry: “The Deep and Savage Way,” Jarome Harmsworth, Joel, Harmsworth
Family Guy: “Drunk with Power,” Walter Murphy
Grimsburg: “Mo11y,” Jesse Novak
Invincible: “You Want a Real Costume, Right?,” John Paesano
Kite Man: Hell Yeah!: “Hero Stuff, Hell Yeah!,” Michael Gatt
Krapopolis: “Love Week,” Joe Wong
The Legend of Vox Machina: “Deadly Echoes,” Neal Acree
#1 Happy Family USA: “Nine Ten,” Moez Dawad
Sausage Party: Foodtopia: “Eighth Course,” Christopher Lennertz, Alexander Bornstein
The Simpsons: “Treehouse of Horror XXXV,” Kara Talve
Solar Opposites: “Live Die Repeat Device,” Chris Westlake
Star Trek: Lower Decks: “The Next New Generation,” Chris Westlake
Terminator Zero: “Model 101,” Michelle Birsky, Kevin Henthorn
Tomb Raider: The Legend of Lara Croft: “Living Midnight,” Pinar Toprak, Gerrit Wunder
Twilight of the Gods: “The Bride-Price,” Hans Zimmerman, Omer Benyamin, Steven Doar
What If…?: “What If…1872?,” Laura Karpman, Nora Kroll-Rosenbaum
Outstanding Original Music and Lyrics
American Dad!: “The Wrong Kid,” Asa Taccone, Nic Wegener
Arcane: “The Line,” Tyler Joseph
Big Mouth: “Is It Normal,” Mark Rivers
Bob’s Burgers: “Drift Too Far,” Nora Smith
Common Side Effects: “The Last - End Song,” Nic Snyder
Devil May Cry: “Afterlife,” Alex Seaver
Exploding Kittens: “Whiskey For Breakfast,” Shane Kosakowski
The Legend of Vox Machina: “Chateau Shorthalt,” Peter Habib, Sam Riegel
#1 Happy Family USA: “Money for the Meat,” Ramy Youssef
The Second Best Hospital in the Galaxy: “Spaceball,” Cirocco Dunlap
Outstanding Main Title Theme Music
Batman: Caped Crusader, Frederik Wiedmann
Common Side Effects, Nic Snyder
Exploding Kittens, Serj Tankian
Lazarus, Kamasi Washington
#1 Happy Family USA, Ramy Youssef, Moez Dawad
Twilight of the Gods, Hans Zimmerman, Omer Benyamin, Steven Doar
Outstanding Music Supervision
Arcane: “Heavy Is the Crown,” Jen Malone, Nicole Weisberg
Devil May Cry: “The First Circle,” Justine Von Winterfeldt, Christina Zabala
Exploding Kittens: “SeaWorld Is Hell,” Ben Sokoler
Invincible: “This Was Supposed to Be Easy,” Gabe Hilfer, Henry van Roden
Outstanding Picture Editing for a Drama Series
Arcane: “Pretend Like It’s the First Time,” Robert Fernandez, Gilda Carmel, Nazim Meslem
Batman: Caped Crusader: “Moving Target,” Marc Stone
Creature Commandos: “Cheers to the Tin Man,” Annie De Brock
Devil May Cry: “The Deep and Savage Way,” Kim Gyung-chan, Kim Min-kyoung
Devil May Cry: “The First Circle,” Kim Gyung Chan, Kyung Min-Ho
Invincible: “I Thought You’d Never Shut Up,” Luke Asa Guidici
The Legend of Vox Machina: “Thordak,” Felipe Salazar, Matt Sipple
Terminator Zero: “Model 101,” Akari Saitoh
Tomb Raider: The Legend of Lara Croft: “Whanaungatanga,” David Howe, Justin Howe, Mohit Jaswal
Twilight of the Gods: “Song of Sigrid,” Chris Lozinski
What If…?: “What If…1872?,” Anton Capaldo-Smith, Adam Spieckermann
Outstanding Picture Editing For a Single Camera Comedy Series
Big Mouth: “Why Do We Go through Puberty?,” Felipe Salazar, Jeremy Arias, Cole Emoff
Bob’s Burgers: “They Slug Horses, Don’t They?,” Jeremy Reuben, Stephanie Earley, Kris Fitzgerald
Common Side Effects: “Cliff’s Edge,” Tony Christopherson
Exploding Kittens: “Let the Games Begin,” Matt Steinauer
Family Guy: “Drunk with Power,” Dennis McElroy, Eric Brown
#1 Happy Family USA: “Egypt Is on the Phone!,” Jeff Picarello
Sausage Party: Foodtopia: “Eighth Course,” Jeff Seibenick
The Second Best Hospital in the Galaxy: “Hoogadoon Bonch,” Megan Love, Clayton Baker
Solar Opposites: “Terry’s Big Cleaning Day,” Nick Reczynski
Star Trek: Lower Decks: “Dos Cerritos,” Andy Maxwell
Outstanding Sound Editing For an Animated Program
Arcane: “The Dirt Under Your Nails”
Batman: Caped Crusader: “Moving Target”
Big Mouth: “Why Do We Go Through Puberty?”
Bob’s Burgers: “Hope N Mic Night”
Castlevania: Nocturne: “Grenadye Alaso”
Common Side Effects: “Raid”
Creature Commandos: “Cheers to the Tin Man”
Devil May Cry: “A River of Blood and Fire”
Exploding Kittens: “Let the Games Begin”
Invincible: “I Thought You’d Never Shut Up”
The Legend of Vox Machina: “Thordak”
Love, Death + Robots: “400 Boys”
#1 Happy Family USA: “Nine Ten”
Sausage Party: Foodtopia: “Seventh Course”
The Second Best Hospital in the Galaxy: “Sedate the Tentacle!”
Secret Level: “Warhammer 40,000: They Shall Know No Fear”
Star Trek: Lower Decks: “The New Next Generation”
Tomb Raider: The Legend of Lara Croft: “A Journey of a Thousand Miles”
Twilight of the Gods: “Song of Sigrid”
What If…?: “What If…1872?”
Outstanding Sound Mixing For a Comedy or Drama (Half-Hour) and Animation
Arcane: “The Dirt Under Your Nails”
Big Mouth: “Why Do We Go Through Puberty?”
Bob’s Burgers: “Hope N Mic Night”
Castlevania: Nocturne: “Grenadye Alaso”
Devil May Cry: “A River of Blood and Fire”
Exploding Kittens: “Let the Games Begin”
Invincible: “I Thought You’d Never Shut Up”
The Legend of Vox Machina: “Thordak”
Love, Death + Robots: “400 Boys”
Sausage Party: Foodtopia: “First Course”
The Second Best Hospital in the Galaxy: “Sedate the Tentacle!”
Secret Level: “Warhammer 40,000: They Shall Know No Fear”
The Simpsons: “The Past and the Furious”
Star Trek: Lower Decks: “A Farewell to Arms”
Tomb Raider: The Legend of Lara Croft: “A Journey of a Thousand Miles”
Twilight of the Gods: “Song of Sigrid”
What If…?: “What If…1872?”
Outstanding Writing for a Comedy Series
Big Mouth: “Homecumming”
Common Side Effects: “Pilot”
Exploding Kittens: “Pilot”
Family Guy: “The Fat Lotus”
Family Guy: “Lois C.K.”
Grimsburg: “Mo11y”
Harley Quinn: “Breaking Brainiac”
Krapopolis: “Krapocalypse”
#1 Happy Family USA: “Nine Ten”
Sausage Party: Foodtopia: “Seventh Course”
The Second Best Hospital in the Galaxy: “Welcome to Pweek”
The Simpsons: “O C’mon All Ye Faithful”
Star Trek: Lower Decks: “The New Next Generation”
Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series
Arcane: “The Message Hidden Within the Pattern”
Batman: “Caped Crusader: Savage Night”
Castlevania: Nocturne: “Monstrous Things”
Creature Commandos: “A Very Funny Monster”
Devil May Cry: “All Hope Abandon”
Invincible: “All I Can Say Is I’m Sorry”
The Legend of Vox Machina: “Hell To Pay”
Terminator Zero: “Model 107”
Tomb Raider: The Legend of Lara Croft: “A Single Step”
Twilight of the Gods: “The Bride-Price”
What If…?: “What If…1872?”
Final Thoughts:
Although honored at the Daytime Emmys, SpongeBob SquarePants never won a Primetime Emmy. Wouldn’t it be funny if Patrick Starship Enterprise finally brought it a win?
Is The Spider Within: A Spider-Verse Story really a commercial? It seems more like a short film.
While not animated, I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention that Craig Zobel, a co-creator of Homestar Runner, is submitted for directing The Penguin pilot “After Hours.”
Nick Spake is the Author of Bright & Shiny: A History of Animation at Award Shows Volumes 1 and 2. Available Now!